birdiethebibliophile:
This is a bit out there, and I absolutely don’t think it’s canon, but hear me out: Lucretia was under the thrall of the Bulwark Staff.
It’s clear that the IPRE aren’t completely immune to the effects of the thrall – they just are the ones who have the chance to overcome it, while everyone else to a person is overcome and gives in. Taako almost gave into the thrall of the Gaia Sash. Magnus was tempted by the Temporal Chalice. Even Davenport seems at one point to be drawn by the Philosopher’s Stone.
Lucretia had possession of the Bulwark Staff almost since she instituted her plan – she said it was easy to recover. The Bulwark Staff does not ever seem to tempt anyone else in the Bureau, as there’s never a hint that it’s a Relic. It would’ve had nearly ten years to draw her in, cement her ideas.
Secondly: the Bulwark Staff is abjuration magic. Abjuration is all about shielding and protecting, and that’s what all of Lucretia’s plan was about. She wanted to shield Faerun from the Hunger, she wanted to shield her friends (her family) from the pain of their decisions, she wanted to shield herself from their dissent against her plan.
Now, the Bulwark Staff didn’t cause Lucretia to institute her plan. That was all her. But why didn’t she turn back when she saw what it did to Davenport, or when Glamour Springs happened, or when she lost twenty years of her life in Wonderland? What made her so stubborn that she would continue for ten years, alone, turning further and further from her family and deeper into a plan conceived of hopelessness?
Well, having a Relic whispering in her ear every moment of that decade that she was doing the right thing, that together they would save everything, that they could protect everyone who needed protecting – in other words, a thrall that just needed to confirm what Lucretia already thought on her own – would probably go a long way towards steering her down that path and keeping her from ever looking back until Taako, through Paloma’s crystal prophesy, showed her a third way and broke through that thrall in the same way that Hurley dying broke through the Gaia Sash’s thrall on Sloane.